Once operators, always operators. We're industry veterans who break down games, apps, and digital businesses for the people actually building them. Read by 15,000+ industry insiders weekly.
Today's newsletter is brought to you by Sensor Tower and VYBS. More about them later...
Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here. Every story this week is really about buying time. Shooters and sports games wait for the GTA wave to pass. Embark trades monthly content for systems that hold players between drops. Roblox bulls want to get out of quarterlies and go back to five years without a public scoreboard. But here's the thing: patience is a strategy only when you know what you are waiting for. โ The three stories of today's newsletter are:
Who gets their ass kicked by GTA VI
ARC Raiders is back. Systems did it, not cosmetics
GTA VI lands on November 19, and the industry is looking for a place to hide. Open World Research put numbers on the fear. Combining its Quarterly Games Survey with PlayDX behavioral data, it found that 69% of PC and console gamers aged 18 and over will definitely or probably play GTA VI at release. Sensor Tower counts 6.1 million US digital pre-orders as of October 13, worth $594 million.
โ
Open World scored 27 titles on two axes: lifetime overlap with past GTA players and stated intent to play GTA VI. The highest risk tier reads like a who's who of console engagement. Competitive shooters such as Call of Duty and Escape from Tarkov, as well as players of key sports franchises, will most likely take a GTA break. Meanwhile, League and Valorant players will continue doing what they do, at least in the short term. Source: Open World Researchโ
What I think is the most interesting finding is that engagement doesnโt appear to be a moat, at least not against GTA. Fortnite, ARC Raiders, and Tarkov players spend 30% or more of their gaming hours in those games, yet all three sit in the highest risk tier. It reads like some of your most loyal players are also the ones most likely to take a month off.
Open World's advice is opposite depending on your franchiseโs risk profile:
If youโre at risk, don't try to battle against the GTA wave by stacking major content, creator moments against the launch. Keep the lights on and save the big re-engagement push for when attention normalizes. No timeline is given for when.
For the low-risk tier, which includes Roblox, Minecraft, Genshin Impact, VALORANT, League of Legends, and Elden Ring, the advice flips. Stay loud while everyone else goes quiet.
If every shooter and sports title goes dark in late November, the low-risk tier gets the stage almost to itself. The contrarian marketing calendar for the year's last quarter might just be built around everyone else's fear of GTA VI. If you have the resources, have your marketing push ready in the chamber so that you can fire when the GTA peak engagement starts to wear off. That would be my advice rather than sitting and waiting for your players to return from their GTA-offsite.
ARC Raiders is back. Systems did it, not cosmetics.
Embark launched ARC Raiders in November 2025 and did what no extraction shooter, let alone a new IP, supposedly can't: crack the top of the charts. It peaked around 3 million DAU across platforms in early 2026, then bled from March onward to an impressive base of roughly 500,000 DAU according to Sensor Towerโs Video Game Insights. Embark's fix surprised people. Fewer updates. Monthly drops gave way to two big drops a year.
The first one, Frozen Trails, paired with a free Steam weekend, pushed players to a six-month high. Xbox and PlayStation lifted too, without a free weekend of their own. New biome for the media cycle, free weekend to remove friction, base game upsell to catch the converted. Clean execution.
Phil's point on the podcast is about what they shipped. Nearly every piece is a system. The skill tree now has gates where you pick one ability over another, and abilities carry conditional effects. More builds are more meta to argue about. Weapons get a level 5 legendary tier as an endgame loop, with a segmentation twist: lose a weapon, and you can't repair it without the right skill.
Phil calls it productivity of content. When your next drop is six months out, you need systems that keep players busy without a team babysitting them.
Where I'm less convinced? A six-month high after a free weekend is a spike until day 30 says otherwise. And the trend is not looking good, with peak CCU already halved since a week ago. The timing is brutal too: Open World puts ARC Raiders in the highest GTA VI risk tier. Then there is capacity. Embark runs a compact team that is probably more measured on AI after the generated-voice backlash.
Phil's answer is blunt. Wind down The Finals, move people to ARC Raiders, and hire co-dev until marginal cost equals marginal benefit. Hard to argue with the math. Albeit I wouldn't dismiss The Finals. A game that retains 30k CCU is an asset. Not something you scoff away for a shinier thing.
Should Roblox go private?
Roblox is now the most-played game on PC and console by total hours, 1.4x Fortnite in H1 2026 per Newzoo and GEEIQ. Yet the stock tells a different story. RBLX closed at $49.55 on October 16, down 65% from its 2025 high.
Source: Newzoo Game Performance Monitor, H1 2026, 37 markets excluding China and India.
โJason Chapman at Konvoy Ventures argues in their fantastic newsletter that Roblox should go private at $65 a share, a 31% premium and $48.4B in total. A club of four to six PE firms, with founder Baszucki rolling his $3.1B stake, $4.5B of balance sheet cash, and $5B of debt. Base case: 20% annual bookings growth, a five-year hold, relist at 6.5x bookings; that's 23.5% IRR (inter.
The logic behind going private is that Roblox is investing in safety, creators, and retention-focused games, and the market punishes it every quarter it's not brain-rotting.
Kress agrees with Jason, which might be the first time in a year he has agreed with a venture capitalist. In his view, revenue leans on Steal-style games like Steal a Brainrot and Steal an Egg, which he considers toxic for kids. Or, in his words, "child torture".
Phil called Eric out on the podcast for laundering a dislike of Baszucki.
Public markets exist for access to capital. Roblox costs track revenue the way Spotify's do, because creator payouts scale with bookings. And Kress is applying boomer taste to kids' play: seven of the top ten by concurrent players are durable games like Brookhaven, Blox Fruits, Adopt Me and Rivals. Steal games spike and fade, so on lifetime LTV they lose. Kress countered that Steal an Egg leads concurrent players by 3x and, by his estimate, monetizes 10 to 20x better than Brookhaven. None of us brought a revenue chart to settle the score.
Source: Rollimons via Max Power Gaming. Concurrent players, not revenue.
Konvoy's own headwinds undercut the thesis. Baszucki controls about 57% of the vote and sits on $6.1B of cash and $1.35B of annual free cash flow. He already has the insulation a buyout would buy. Thin EBITDA makes the deal roughly 80% equity, and the IRR depends on the same market re-rating the stock that the thesis says gets Roblox wrong. In other words, going private doesn't fix a strategy.
AI is causing an avalanche of new games on Roblox, with first-time game makers launching 10-times more games than just a couple of months ago. Roblox takes two-thirds of developers' revenue because it handles distribution for them. But will it hold true at this rate of new content?
One variable neither side priced in. Games from first-time makers starting Roblox ads are up 10.5x per day since early August, most of it after late September. They are now half of all new ad games. More supply chasing the same players means pricier discovery. The question that settles the debate is which experiences make Roblox's money over three years, not three months.
โState of Game Advertising 2026 tracks how publishers in both the PC/Console and mobile space promoted their titles across 41 markets. You will not find more complete analysis on gaming marketing anywhere else!
Built by industry experts, VYBS is the fastest-growing loyalty platform for mobile games.
VYBS is now featuring AI-powered targeting, a loyalty meta layer, and an ROAS optimization engine that helps game developers both monetize and retain players like never before.
VYBS is built differently. It's designed for growth.
My wife uninstalled Roblox from our iPads, so I brought on Roblox's Chief Safety Officer Matt Kaufman and VP of Safety Products Eliza Jacobs to pressure-test every safety claim. We get into the new Roblox Kids and Select accounts, how facial age estimation works at scale (and how parents keep breaking it), AI moderation across 150 million daily users, why Roblox banned the viral "predator hunters" anyway, and how bad actors try to pull kids off-platform.
Shooter Monthly #2: Call of Duty Flops, Battlefield Hops, and Arc Raiders Pops
Call of Duty's worst launch in a decade collides with the extraction shooter boom. Phillip Black, Chris Sides and Feras Musmar dig into why Black Ops 7 cratered, how Battlefield 6 stole the spotlight and why ARC Raiders is suddenly the most important new IP in shooters, plus Tarkov's rough 1.0 launch, matchmaking as an economic problem and whether Embark should go all in on ARC Raiders.
Once operators, always operators. We're industry veterans who break down games, apps, and digital businesses for the people actually building them. Read by 15,000+ industry insiders weekly.
Hello friend, Every story this week sets conviction against evidence. Sands had the conviction to fund 440 people and no proof that a game would hold players. Brussels has conviction about harm to children and no data on the age split. Developers are convinced AI is hurting them and yes use it more than ever. The one company in this issue that runs on evidence keeps an unprecedented 84% margin. Conviction is what gets you started. Itโs the evidence that decides who is still standing when the...
Happy Friday, friend! Four countries in seven days, and somewhere between a boarding gate and a hotel lobby, I missed the TWIG recording once again. So I did what our listeners do and watched it. Jen, Kress, Laura Taranto, and Josh Chandley brought the insights with the fund in the latest episode. Four stories stuck with me: Roblox beat their number, and yet the stock went into another free-fall Block Blast, one of my favorite mobile games, has been lying to us about ads Anthropic added two...
TWIG #407: Roblox's Steal Economy, Tim Sweeney Goes All In on AI while Xbox Loses Its COO For maximum insight and entertainment, watch the full TWIG podcast with hosts Jen Donahoe, Eric Kress, Phillip Black and guest host Adam Telfer (YouTube / Apple / Spotify). Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here. I skipped this weekโs recording for a padel courts and dinners in Limassol and Tel Aviv. It's truly heartwarming to see you, our readers and listeners from around the world, in real life. Jen...