🎮 The Big Roblox's Debate and Dilemma


TWIG #407: Roblox's Steal Economy, Tim Sweeney Goes All In on AI while Xbox Loses Its COO

For maximum insight and entertainment, watch the full TWIG podcast with hosts Jen Donahoe, Eric Kress, Phillip Black and guest host Adam Telfer (YouTube / Apple / Spotify).

video preview​

Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here.

I skipped this week’s recording for a padel courts and dinners in Limassol and Tel Aviv. It's truly heartwarming to see you, our readers and listeners from around the world, in real life.

Jen christened this week as Mishka-free Wednesday. Eric, Phillip, and returning guest star host Adam Telfer filled the gap by arguing about stolen brainrots, Call of Duty comps, and Xbox’s org chart. I listened to the episode on a morning run, and three stories deserve more than a listen. Roblox reported Q3 last night, so we start there.

Today's newsletter is brought to you by Heroic Labs and Appcharge. More about them later...


Roblox: The 50% That Is and Isn’t

“Fifty percent of the revenue in 2025 was driven by games in which you steal toys from children.” Eric Kress

Eric and Phil both brought charts for a rematch from last week. Kress opened with a big number and even more confidence. Phil called the steal games a crust on the pizza, not the pizza. But despite the graphs, neither has the full picture, because Roblox publishes no game-level dollars.

Start with Creator Exchange’s estimate of 2025 payouts to the top 25 games. Grow a Garden paid out $150M+ and Steal a Brainrot $90M+. That’s $240M of roughly $740M, about a third. To reach Eric’s half, you have to add Blox Fruits and Plants vs Brainrots, and even then you land at 43%. Phil’s own data files Blox Fruits under staples with no stealing loop.

But that's semantics. Zoom out to the platform and the share shrinks again. Creator Exchange estimates the two steal hits generated over $1B for Roblox in under a year. Roblox booked $6.8B in 2025. Call it 15%. Remarkable for two games each "built in a week". Yet, it's still nowhere near a half.

Eric's original 50% statement doesn't hold up. Yet there's a 50% that does, and it sits in the same chart’s footnote. Games launched in 2025 made more than half of Roblox’s 2025 revenue. That’s the real story. Roblox is a novelty machine, and in 2025 it just happened that novelty looked like theft.

Phil’s rank data shows the half-life. Grow a Garden fell from #1 to #58 on Roblox’s Top Earning chart. Steal a Brainrot sits at #13. Rivals, Adopt Me, Blox Fruits and Brookhaven hold the top ten without a stealing loop between them.

Nevertheless, Eric is right where it matters for the stock. The 2025 surge in DAU and bookings came from these games. Roblox tried to steer discovery away from them, then steered back. His line: “Are you gonna really move these people to a game called Volleyball Legends?" No. Volleyball Legends paid out $9.8M last year. Grow a Garden paid out fifteen times that.

From my perspective as someone working with a Roblox studio for over a year, the morality debate misses the design lesson. Steal loops convert loss aversion into session frequency. Your stuff is at risk while you’re offline, so you log back in. Clash of Clans and every mobile 4X built empires on the same raid tension. The difference is the audience. That's a regulatory risk more than a product one.

Q3 landed last night. As Eric predicted during the podcast, bookings of $1.7B beat the top of guidance but were down 12% year over year, and daily users fell 9% to 138M. There's a real dilemma here. The platform Roblox wants to be is different than the platform that grows. With a serious push towards AI tooling and deeper, high-production-value games, Roblox will either be going against what its audience wants or succeed in expanding its audience. Short-term pain for a long-term gain, if it works.

​>> The full conversation on YouTube​


Modern Warfare 4: Fixed the Gun and the Franchise

Infinity Ward shipped the best Call of Duty in years. Metacritic sits at 86, against 66 for Black Ops 7. Adam played through the campaign and came back raving about the gunplay. Eric called it an easy comp and a real jump.

“Modern Warfare 4, in terms of feedback, recoil and audio feedback, is absolutely next level. Great job by Infinity Ward.”

The design changes read like a rejection of last year. And no wonder. Black Ops 7 reached a Metacritic score of under 70 and got buried by Battlefield 6 to a point where the entire franchise was in doubt. Hipfire bloom is gone, so bullets land where the gun points. Movement is grounded again. Apex attachments unlock at max weapon level and change what a gun does, the closest CoD has come to a horizontal endgame. Kill Block, a dynamic, evolving multiplayer map with a round-based game mode, is a content-cost play at its finest. And MW4 skips Game Pass at launch. You tell us what that signals about the subscription model...

Phil flagged the change that could bite monetization. The new Gunnery Sergeant builds a full loadout in one click from attachments you already own. Blueprints, which Phil pegs at half of CoD’s monetization model, are paid UX shortcuts. Give the shortcut away, and you could be very well in the cannibalization territory.

Now the numbers. On Steam, MW4 peaked at 227,406 concurrent players on day one. That beats MWIII and Black Ops 7 and trails MWII and Black Ops 6. Four days in, it was down 27% from peak, a steeper slide than either game it trails.

It was easy to agree with Adam’s framing. Infinity Ward years are supposed to reset the peak that carries the next two releases, and in his words, “forecasts don’t care about external circumstances.” Eric’s counter is fair too. The franchise was written off a year ago, and climbing out of that hole was the job.

Two caveats cut in MW4’s favor. Early access pulled engagement forward as MW4 ran well above its predecessors in the week before launch, which is, as Jen puts it, pre-order unlock doing its job. Then there’s Xbox. On PlayStation, MW4 runs far ahead of Black Ops 7 in estimated DAU. On Xbox, it trails, because MW4 didn’t launch into Game Pass day one. Fewer players, more buyers. That’s a trade Microsoft chose.

GTA VI lands in three weeks and will eat the tail regardless. But here's the biggest win: Quality buys sentiment, and sentiment pays out a year later. If Treyarch and Raven get the development time Infinity Ward clearly had, next year’s Black Ops cashes this check.

​>> The full conversation on YouTube​


Xbox: Not for Sale, Getting Priced Anyway

We actively try to skip Xbox stories and repeat ourselves on the podcast. But four Xbox stories landed in one week. There was no way we could have dodged them all.

The Information reported that 1) private equity firms explored buying Xbox at a $100B to $150B valuation. The top of that range is nearly three times EA’s $55B Saudi-led take-private move. The talks were exploratory, and Microsoft says Xbox is not for sale. 2) Microsoft then offered voluntary exits to about 60,000 employees, more than a quarter of its full-time workforce, Xbox included. 3) Netflix offered $500M for seven years of exclusive film and TV rights to Xbox IP. Xbox countered at $800M, and Netflix walked. 4) Then Helen Chiang, Xbox’s first COO and a 21-year Microsoft veteran who once ran Minecraft, left three months into the job with no successor named.

Eric reads the buyout leak as a banker’s stalking horse offer: float a number and see who builds a coalition. Plausible. Here's an even simpler take. A weather balloon of a leak that costs Microsoft nothing and potentially anchors a price.

“Just take the money and run.” Jen Donahoe on Netflix's $500M offer to Xbox

I’d push back on Jen when she encouraged Xbox to take the money and run. Two weeks earlier, Xbox CEO Asha Sharma launched XP, a division for film, TV, licensing and live experiences, run by Mojang chief Kayleen Walters. Selling seven years of exclusivity to one buyer would have gutted it at birth. A Minecraft Movie grossed close to $1B on its own, and $71M a year is too cheap for the entire catalog. Jen’s sharper point stands, though. The IP worth licensing is the IP Microsoft bought: Minecraft, Blizzard, King. Not Halo. Not Gears.

Chiang, a 21-year Xbox veteran and a newly minted COO who abruptly departed after weeks on the job, is the story that should worry people. Eric’s timeline: she gets end-to-end P&L in July, but Mojang and King report straight to Sharma. On October 8, Sharma names Walters to XP and ex-Reddit product chief Maria Angelidou-Smith to Mojang, both reporting to her. Chiang’s name is absent. Two weeks later she’s gone. Eric heard she objected to where the studios and IP were heading. Microsoft hasn’t explained the exit. Or maybe she simply didn’t buy the vision Sharma was hired to execute.

As a fractional COO who has gone through more re-orgs than I care to remember, here's my take: In an organization where the biggest cash machines report around you, you're not holding an operating role. You're holding the title of a chief janitor dealing with everything but the crown jewels. Based on the timeline, it looks like the crown jewels were moved from under her after the appointment.

​>> The full conversation on YouTube​

SOURCES
​
This Week in Games #407​
​
Creator Exchange, Top 100 Roblox games 2025​
​
GamesBeat, Roblox Q4 2025 results​
​
Windows Central, Xbox PE valuation report​
​
VGC, Xbox and Netflix​
​
PC Gamer, Microsoft voluntary exits​
​
Gematsu, Helen Chiang departure​
​
TheWrap, Xbox launches XP​



Newsletter

Game industry insights. Delivered weekly.

​Sign Up →​

Slack Community

Largest senior community in the industry

​Join +4,000 Professionals →​

Let Us Help

Real experts. Measurable results.

​See our referencesl→​


🌏 From Our World-Class Partners

Gram Games used Heroic Labs to tailor offers and events by player cohort, calling it "critical" in a post-IDFA world where retention is everything. Read how Gram merged personalization and advanced social features into a core system of their live operations.
​

​

The House Always Kept a Third, Until Now.

Appcharge is your proven partner. $1 billion + in transactions processed across top titles. No platform middlemen. No fragmented handoffs between payment vendors. No watching your LTV models fall apart because you don't own the checkout experience.

Own your players. Own your revenue. Own your economics.

Reinvent how you monetize >>> Appcharge.com​

​

🎬 Fresh Clips

The Games Market Is Growing. Or Is It?

video preview​

Adjusted for inflation, the industry’s big growth story shrinks to around 2% a year.

The team breaks down Newzoo’s latest numbers: Western spenders driving the gains, downloads dropping while CPIs rise 30%, and five companies accounting for almost all of last year’s growth. They also discuss how China competes from a protected home market, why console spend sticks to existing titles, and what all this means for new studios.
​

Google Wants You to Prompt Games

video preview​

Type an idea, get a playable game. Google is the latest to try.

The team breaks down Google Playground, its upcoming Unity Spark integration, and how it stacks up against Roblox Build and Meta’s Horizon Create. They also discuss why locking out under-18s and offering no creator payouts is a tough start, what Stadia taught everyone about Google and gaming, and why tools alone won’t build an audience.


Deconstructor of Fun P.C.

Plateia Ippodameias 8, Peiraios, Athens 18531
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Deconstructor of Fun

Once operators, always operators. We're industry veterans who break down games, apps, and digital businesses for the people actually building them. Read by 15,000+ industry insiders weekly.

Read more from Deconstructor of Fun

Hello friend, Every story this week sets conviction against evidence. Sands had the conviction to fund 440 people and no proof that a game would hold players. Brussels has conviction about harm to children and no data on the age split. Developers are convinced AI is hurting them and yes use it more than ever. The one company in this issue that runs on evidence keeps an unprecedented 84% margin. Conviction is what gets you started. It’s the evidence that decides who is still standing when the...

Happy Friday, friend! Four countries in seven days, and somewhere between a boarding gate and a hotel lobby, I missed the TWIG recording once again. So I did what our listeners do and watched it. Jen, Kress, Laura Taranto, and Josh Chandley brought the insights with the fund in the latest episode. Four stories stuck with me: Roblox beat their number, and yet the stock went into another free-fall Block Blast, one of my favorite mobile games, has been lying to us about ads Anthropic added two...

🎉 Join us at our upcoming events 🎉Executive Supper Club: Limassol - October 26The Padel Club: Limassol - October 27 Today's newsletter is brought to you by Sensor Tower and VYBS. More about them later... Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here. Every story this week is really about buying time. Shooters and sports games wait for the GTA wave to pass. Embark trades monthly content for systems that hold players between drops. Roblox bulls want to get out of quarterlies and go back to five years...