🎮 The Three Turkish Problems


🎉 Join us at our upcoming events 🎉

​Roundtables: San Mateo - October 19 (Zynga HQ, waitlist only)
​Executive Supper Club: Limassol - October 26
​The Padel Club: Limassol - October 27

Today's newsletter is brought to you by AppsFlyer and Appcharge. More about them later...


Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here. We're trying something new. Instead of giving you short clips of the key news stories at the end of the week, we'll offer a bit of a deeper dive into one or two of them. Let me know how it reads.​

This week I kept coming back to two questions. What happens to the hungriest founders in games once they win? And what happens to a good game when the platform behind it can't sell it? Istanbul answered the first one for me. Gears of War answered the second.

  • Hungry founders build companies, not ecosystems. TĂĽrkiye's rivalry made it the mobile capital of the world. Now it stops founders from learning, and the winners rarely stay.
  • Gears of War is a good game nobody paid for. E-Day reviewed well, with a commendable Metacritic score of 88, and sold only about 230,000 copies, nearly three times more on Steam than on Xbox. Xbox has a distribution problem and a product problem, and XP won't fix either.

For maximum insight and entertainment, watch the full TWIG podcast with hosts Eric Kress, Phillip Black, and yours truly (YouTube / Apple / Spotify).

video preview​

Fresh off Mobidictum in Istanbul, we ask Phil why Turkey became the puzzle capital, and Sweden didn’t. Aream’s Q3 M&A figure looks healthy until Mishka strips out EA. In other news, Eric breaks down why Xbox XP makes all the sense, just not now.

What Makes Turkish Founders Excel Is What Holds The Ecosystem Back

Being close to many Turkish founders and investors, I’ve had the privilege of watching this ecosystem balloon up close. I’ve praised the sometimes ruthless rivalry that built it. I believe it was talent density, hunger, and rivalry that made the impossible feel possible. And when the founder who looks like you on the other side of the Bosphorus makes it, why can't you? Add a generous surge of venture capital, and puzzle town of Istanbul became the mobile gaming capital of the world.

But I also believe that same rivalry now works against the ecosystem. Most Turkish founders never drop the scarcity mindset, no matter how many millions of downloads their games rack up or how many zeroes their latest round carries.

You’d assume you could learn to craft the perfect puzzle level just by walking down İstiklal Street. Wrong. I’ve organized events in Istanbul ranging from intimate gatherings of 50 founders to events with 1,000 developers. One thing holds true. Turkish founders very rarely get on panels or do fireside chats. And many of the most successful ones don’t show up. The lack of knowledge sharing is a problem.

Then there’s the bigger problem: the talent pool. Turkish gaming companies hire only Turks, only in their city. There’s no remote work. It’s 12-hour days, often six days a week. Istanbul has 16 million+ people, but only so many great designers, programmers, and PMs. For a Turkish founder, every competitor is also a poacher. And we all know what you do with poachers...

There are two fixes. For the talent shortage, co-development gives you on-demand talent without the overhead. Supercell, for example, actively uses co-development to keep its internal teams compact. For the rivalry, angel investing turns it from toxic to healthy. When you own a slice of your competitor, their success is your success too.

The rivalry that built the ecosystem now prevents it from evolving.

The third problem starts after the exit, and to fix it, the mindset needs to change. Turkish founders are the hungriest I know. At the same time, in my experience, they aren’t passionate about games. They’re passionate about the business of games, which is exactly why they’re so good at it. And because it’s business rather than passion, once the hunger is satisfied, they peace out.

Sidar Şahin showed at Peak how to build a marvelous company, and also set the example for what to do once it sells. Ghost everyone. Compare that to Supercell’s Ilkka Paananen, who personally mentors and invests in the next generation of founders. Can you imagine the startup scene in Istanbul if successful Turkish founders methodically invested their time and know-how in the next wave?

Four months ago, I called the Turkish gaming market overheated and expected valuations to fall as failures compounded and the market saturated. I was wrong. More big exits are coming, and it will only heat up the market further without fixing the three structural problems. The winners continue to hire the best people in Istanbul. The emerging rivals will continue to get overfunded by VCs who missed the best deals and will pay anything for an “ex-Peak team.”

So I push the founders I work with to escape the shrinking talent pool through co-development and diaspora hires, and to take secondaries in their monster rounds instead of selling at the first great offer and peacing out.

I'm not blaming founders for selling and moving on. I'm only saying that founders who stay build ecosystems.

Read more on the blog:

Gears of War Is a Very Good Game Nobody Paid For

Gears of War: E-Day reviewed well with a Metacritic score reaching 88, which makes its launch numbers sting even more. Image: Xbox Game Studios / The Coalition

Gears of War: E-Day reviewed well. On launch day, it ranked fourth among Xbox titles by players, behind only Fortnite, Roblox and NBA 2K27. And according to Alinea, it sold roughly 230,000 copies in its first week. 168,000 on Steam. 62,000 on Xbox.

Read that again. Xbox's flagship shooter sold nearly three times as many copies on Valve's store as on its own platform. On the show, we guessed two million units and $90 million. The data is worse.

Alinea estimates 722K Game Pass players paid the $30 Premium upgrade, against 62K full copies sold on Xbox. Source: Alinea Analytics.

The defense, and why it does not hold

The bull case goes like this. Units are the wrong metric in a subscription world. 1.7 million Game Pass players jumped in. 722,000 of them paid the extra $30 for the Premium Edition Game Pass upgrade and five days of early access. Almost a million people paid something, and Xbox delivered roughly three-quarters of an estimated $37 million in revenue.

Fine. But $37 million is the number for a flagship franchise. Nobody outside Microsoft knows the budget. The $400 million rumor has been widely discredited, and Eric puts it closer to $200 to $300 million. Even at the low end, this is nowhere near break-even, and premium shooters decay fast. Give it two months, and it lives in the discount bin.

The $30 Premium Edition Game Pass upgrade did not grow the pie. It replaced the $70 SKU with a cheaper one.

This is not a quality problem. Distribution beats quality.

Xbox does not have distribution. US Xbox hardware sales are down 33% this year through August, according to Circana. When you lose the console war and keep exclusives, you pay the tax twice. You lose the hardware margin, and you lose the software sales your own games would have made on the bigger platform. On PlayStation, with a real Steam push, Eric thinks E-Day does four to five million units. I think he is roughly right.

When you lose the console war and keep exclusives, you lose both the hardware margin, and you lose the software sales.

But it is a product problem

Here Phil is right, and the quality argument runs out. Gears gave the industry Horde mode back in 2008. Co-op PvE against endless waves was its idea. Helldivers 2 took that blueprint and turned it into a live service business. Gears never did. Halo has the same story: an arena shooter that never evolved into a serious Call of Duty competitor.

Nearly twtwo-thirdsf E-Day's Steam players also play Helldivers 2, the co-op audience Horde was built for. Source: Alinea Analytics

The counterargument is that the live service graveyard is full, and Gears fans want a campaign, not a battle pass. True. But a premium campaign that launches into a shrinking install base needs a reason for players to stay between releases. Gears had one and left it on the shelf.


Newsletter

Game industry insights. Delivered weekly.

​Sign Up →​

Slack Community

Largest senior community in the industry

​Join +4,000 Professionals →​

Let Us Help

Real experts. Measurable results.

​See our references​→​


🌏 From Our World-Class Partners

Up from 53%. Meanwhile, $7M+ spenders grew creative variations 46% YoY. AppsFlyer analyzed 1.2M creatives across 1,400+ apps to show what actually wins on video vs. image.

​

The House Always Kept a Third, Until Now.

Appcharge is your proven partner. $1 billion + in transactions processed across top titles. No platform middlemen. No fragmented handoffs between payment vendors. No watching your LTV models fall apart because you don't own the checkout experience.

Own your players. Own your revenue. Own your economics.

Reinvent how you monetize >>> Appcharge.com​

​

🎧 Fresh From the Pod

How TĂĽrkiye Became the New Capital of Mobile Gaming

​APPLE / 🎧 SPOTIFY / ▶️ YOUTUBE​

My panel with Laton Ventures founder Görkem Türk, Grand Games CEO Batuhan Çelebi and Gram Games co-founder Mehmet Ecevit on what makes the Turkish ecosystem unique, data-driven design, and keeping culture while scaling.

Questions Istanbul Founders Stopped Asking with Akın Babayiğit

​APPLE / 🎧 SPOTIFY / ▶️ YOUTUBE​

The Tripledot co-founder, now running the $100M Arcadia Gaming Partners fund, on Istanbul as both insider and outsider.

Deconstructor of Fun P.C.

Plateia Ippodameias 8, Peiraios, Athens 18531
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Deconstructor of Fun

Once operators, always operators. We're industry veterans who break down games, apps, and digital businesses for the people actually building them. Read by 15,000+ industry insiders weekly.

Read more from Deconstructor of Fun

Hello friend, Every story this week sets conviction against evidence. Sands had the conviction to fund 440 people and no proof that a game would hold players. Brussels has conviction about harm to children and no data on the age split. Developers are convinced AI is hurting them and yes use it more than ever. The one company in this issue that runs on evidence keeps an unprecedented 84% margin. Conviction is what gets you started. It’s the evidence that decides who is still standing when the...

Happy Friday, friend! Four countries in seven days, and somewhere between a boarding gate and a hotel lobby, I missed the TWIG recording once again. So I did what our listeners do and watched it. Jen, Kress, Laura Taranto, and Josh Chandley brought the insights with the fund in the latest episode. Four stories stuck with me: Roblox beat their number, and yet the stock went into another free-fall Block Blast, one of my favorite mobile games, has been lying to us about ads Anthropic added two...

TWIG #407: Roblox's Steal Economy, Tim Sweeney Goes All In on AI while Xbox Loses Its COO For maximum insight and entertainment, watch the full TWIG podcast with hosts Jen Donahoe, Eric Kress, Phillip Black and guest host Adam Telfer (YouTube / Apple / Spotify). Happy Friday, friend! Mishka here. I skipped this week’s recording for a padel courts and dinners in Limassol and Tel Aviv. It's truly heartwarming to see you, our readers and listeners from around the world, in real life. Jen...